Frozen hit the theaters November 27 2013. It was... a HUGE hit.
It made $243,390 on opening weekend and everyone... and I mean EVERYONE was singing the songs and talking about it
Many people considered this "The return of Disney" or Disney's way of telling the world... "I'm bringing animation back".
And with good reason. Dreamworks had just released Despicable Me 2 (And it wasn't a bad film) but a lot of people (including myself) started to get tired of animated movies. We were watching the same thing over and over and over... Cool people doing cool things acting in a cool way.
What do I mean?
Well, that year, we saw the following releases
1)Planes by Pixar...
2) The Croods by Dreamworks Animation
3) Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2
4) Monsters University
5) Despicable Me 2
All of these films had the same idea. Not the same message. I never saw Planes (and I don't plan to), but out of the other 4 films, I see a pattern of pleasing towards the audience by becoming products of their time.
Sure, The Croods was set upon cave-men/women but it still very simple formula. Same with all the other films. They all talk "hip" and try to convey a bridge between the audience and the characters. Most of the time, they fail. Pretty bad. They end up by looking like that one kid who tries too hard to look cool by talking like the others, while everyone knows they are out of their comfort zone
I may be talking just out of personal experience, but I was kind of getting sick these people trying to talk a language that is not theirs. There was no genuineness and no real threat or story. Safe bet after safe bet after safe bet.
I felt like there was nothing new anymore. Add to the fact that most of the live action movies were taken from books... So, originality was kind of gone.
Then Frozen came out.
I remember seeing the trailer for this film and I was already like
I was skeptical. I didn't want to watch it, because I thought it was going to be Tangled 2... return of the awful franchise.
But it wasn't. After seeing it for the first time... everyone was under one voice singing out loud "Let it Go!!!"
I... I... I didn't like this movie.
It was strange... I didn't like a movie I was supposed to like. I saw it time and time again, looking for things to hate, but nothing came. Yet I still wasn't getting the entire hype. (I did memorize the songs... by accident).
But, enough about the past.
Now to future.
I recently saw it again, and I don't think it holds up.
GET YOUR FIRE TORCHES AND PITCHFORKS HERE FOR THE PUBLIC ATTACK ON MAU'S OPINION!!!
I mean... it's not horrible. Out of 5, I give it a solid 3.5. I think the movie is a great turn of events. I think that it is actually Disney's way of telling the world "Let ME teach you kids how it's done". But throughout the Frozen craze, people were saying "ooo It's as good as Lion King" or "It's even better than Beauty and the Beast", or (the one that made me take another look at it) "Probably Disney's best work yet".
Well, let me tell you.
It's not.
It's a good film, but not a great one. I don't think it belongs in "Disney's top 5 movies". I'm sorry... I just don't see it
Why?
Well, let's look at the story.
Frozen (SPOILER ALERT BTW) is about a princess with the power to turn things to ice. She (out of an incredible pressure of hiding her powers) curses her hometown in infinite weather and her sister, Anna, teams up with a mountain man, his playful reindeer and a snowman to change the weather condition. (As basic as you are going to get... I know there is more to it... but meh)
The story is based upon the story of the Snow Queen, but because I am not looking at source material, it doesn't really matter.
So, first, let's talk about the good things.
1) The animation and the setting. HOLY CRAP... Stunning, beautiful setting. Every snowflake was probably designed individually so that the amount of detail going into it would be perfect. It feels big and powerful. There is a real sense of being in another world. The entire idea that it is set in a place we don't know during a time that is "sorta viking-ish" I think plays out great.
2) The music.... I don't wanna go into too much detail on this one... but it is great
3) The villain is almost perfect...
Hans is freaking awesome as a villain. Had me guessing the entire time and I did not expect him to become the evil one... The only thing I have a problem with is his motivation. He wants to rule the land.
Come ON!!!! We've seen this already... plain ambition... He is a freaking prince, what more do you want???
You could make the argument that because he is the youngest of a big family, there will be no kingdom for him to rule. I would be lying if I said I didn't understand that. But, he doesn't act like the youngest of a family. He seems like he was in control.
Let me see him strive for attention, let me see him being actually treated like the youngest. Instead, he is this evil mastermind that just wants to rule the kingdom. A little bit overdone if you ask me.
(BTW For me, the perfect villain is Gaston).
What are the problems?
1) The characters. There are a lot of characters in this film. And all of them are "safe" archetypes of classic tales.
We have the hero (or heroine) who wants more out of life than her boring life in the castle... Thats!!--- really boring... we've seen that with...well... most of the other princesses in Disney.
You have the OTHER Heroine/Villain. A tortured soul, Elsa tries to live a life of peace and quiet where she can enjoy her lifestyle without the pressure of everyone else set on her.
As original as this is, well, it's not the greatest idea for kids. What are you saying? That if I feel pressured into being a responsible young man... I should run away because I really feel comfortable being a lazy person? In the end, Elsa learns that "Love" is the best way to live her life with her powers and be accepted by everyone. That is really just, boring.
I did like the idea that it wasn't a kiss that thawed out the Anna's frozeness, but rather an act of pure love out of the sister... that was genius, I actually like that. Fraternal love. I can get behind that.
You have the dude with his reindeer. O, I hate this guy, Kristoff.
He is to men, what (many people say) Ariel is to women. Simplifying them to a level of almost insulting. He is played as a dumb guy obsessed with his reindeer and his sleigh, he is cold and doesn't care about feelings. He is basically the stereotype of a stereotype. I really don't like him, because he is just a DUDE...
And of course.... Olaf.
Oh, Olaf... I know you mean well. I know that you are meant to be innocent and cute and pretty. I can't stand you.
I really cannot stand you. Everything you say is covered with rainbows and butterflies and cutesy wittle bwaby twalk. It gets sick after a while. I wanted to see something funny, but at the same time, take a serious tone to it. That scene where he is melting for Anna, was MEANT to be serious... but THOSE EYES... I cannot take him seriously. He is too cute for everyone to go "AWWWWW" that it drives me sick.
The last problem I have with this movie is the after effect.
What is it questioning?
What kind of impact is it leaving on me as a viewer?
Well, just songs. Songs that are great, don't get me wrong. But the songs are the only thing that it is left for this thing. People sing the songs to this day. And that is the only thing that it has going for it. It is so good that it becomes it's downfall. Because of the goodness of the songs, the rest of the movie becomes forgettable. Now, in other cases, the fact that the movie is forgettable means that the movie didn't try hard enough.... not with Frozen. They tried their best, but their trump card was the songs, and with comparison, the rest of the movie didn't stand a chance.
But, all of this is just on a PERSONAL opinion. I'm not saying that I am right, or that you are wrong if you love it. I am just saying what I think of the film. I saw some flaws... that in other movies, I don't see.
I personally think that even though it is a good film, I wouldn't say that it is Disney's best. Overall, I still think Disney still has to show us what they can really do with 3D animation.